Reviews
Review: Lone Survivor
- Details
- Written by Matthew Toomey
Directed by: | Peter Berg |
Written by: | Peter Berg |
Starring: | Mark Wahlberg, Taylor Kitsch, Emile Hirsch, Ben Foster, Eric Bana, Alexander Ludwig |
Released: | February 20, 2014 |
Grade: | B+ |
Lone Survivor is based on a 2005 true story and follows four U.S. Navy SEALs who were part of a team trying to gather surveillance on an important Taliban leader. They were to hide in the mountains near Asadabad, observe the goings-on in a nearby village, and then report key details back to their base (who could plan an attack).
It’s not as easy as it might sound. This mission, described in the film as one with “a lot of moving parts”, went pear shaped after the four men lost their communications and were then seen by a goat herder and his two young sons. They were soon set upon by a sizeable Taliban army who knew the mountains very, very well.
You might ask yourself the question – why the hell is the film called Lone Survivor? Isn’t that giving away the ending? The answer to question is “yes” but it’s not as big a spoiler as you might think. Firstly, the movie is based on the novel “Lone Survivor” written by Marcus Luttrell – the man who did live to tell to the tale. Secondly, the story is told by way of flashback. We see a badly injured Luttrell at the start… and we then slip back a few days to see how he got there.
This is an intense film. You get a clear sense of the panic these guys felt and the hopelessness of their situation. You’ll also feel their pain as they desperately throw themselves off mountain cliffs and onto to further rocks below. It’s been well shot by actor-turned-director Peter Berg (Battleship) who has also assembled a strong cast headlined by Mark Wahlberg, Taylor Kitsch, Emile Hirsch and Ben Foster. Australian Eric Bana makes an appearance as the team’s base commander.
Berg, who adapted the screenplay, also takes the time to explore a moral angle. When the four SEALs are discovered by the goat herder and his sons, there’s a heated debate amongst the soldiers as to what to do. Do they follow the Rules of Engagement and let them go on the basis that they are innocent civilians? Or should they be killed to eliminate the risk that they’ll return home and alert the Taliban leaders?
There have been a few question marks about the film’s authenticity since its release in the United States last month. It would appear that some scenes have been embellished for dramatic effect. Those critics have a point (the over-dramatisation is too obvious in places) but on the whole, I don’t believe the film’s themes or messages have been lost. I’ve watched a few interviews with the real Marcus Luttrell and he too appears to be satisfied with what ended up on screen. Hopefully you’ll feel the same way.
Review: Nebraska
- Details
- Written by Matthew Toomey
Directed by: | Alexander Payne |
Written by: | Bob Nelson |
Starring: | Bruce Dern, Will Forte, June Squibb, Bob Odenkirk, Stacy Keach, Mary Louise Weston |
Released: | February 20, 2014 |
Grade: | A |
The opening shot in Nebraska is that of an old man slowly walking down the side of a busy road. His name is Woody Grant (Dern) and he has set out on a 1,300km trek from his home in Billings, Montana. It’s not a “bucket list” thing. It’s not a “raise money for charity” thing. Woody believes he’s won a $1 million sweepstakes prize and so he’s trying to walk to the company’s offices in Lincoln, Nebraska to claim it.
So why isn’t he being driven by his family? Well, they know that Woody hasn’t won the $1 million prize. The letter that arrived in the mail is just a standard gimmick used by publishing companies to make people buy magazine subscriptions. They try to explain this to the eighty-something year old Woody, who is showing early signs of dementia, but he just doesn’t comprehend. He’s convinced he’s won the money. It prompts his wife (Squibb) to say “I didn’t know the son of a bitch even wanted to be a millionaire!”
Left with no other option, his son David (Forte) takes a few days off work and agrees to drive him. It’ll be a chance for them to spend some quality time together (something they haven’t done in a while). Further, once they reach the sweepstakes offices, Woody will finally understand that he’s not a prize winner. They can then drive back home and life can return to normal.
If you’ve seen the trailer, you’ll know that things don’t quite go as expected. A quick detour through Woody’s old home town of Hawthorne goes pear shaped when he starts telling all his old friends that he’s now a millionaire. Some folk are happy for Woody. The local newspaper wants to do an article on his “rags to riches” story for example. On the flipside, some folk are not so happy. Old business partners and seldom-seen family members are now buttering him up and seeking a slice of the cash. It’s starting to get out of control…
Accompanied by a sleepy music score from composer Mark Orton, Nebraska is another wonderful feature film from director Alexander Payne (Election, Sideways, The Descendants). Curiously, this is his first film where he isn’t also credited as a screenwriter. Payne was shown Bob Nelson’s script by two colleagues and asked who he thought would be a good fit as a director. His response – “how about me?”
As a huge fan of the early years of cinema, Nebraska has allowed Payne to do something he’s always wanted to do – make a black and white movie. It’s not a silent film but you can see that dialogue has been used sparingly. There’s a great scene where Woody and his brothers are sitting in a living room in front of the television. They’re not a talkative bunch. Words aren’t required though. Just watching them put a smile on a face.
Using a mix of both professional and non-professional actors, Payne has brought together a superb cast. In the leading role, 77-year-old Bruce Dern (Coming Home, Monster) has created a character that is tragic yet funny, repulsive yet endearing. When asked why he’d never left his wife, despite years of bickering, his response sums up his harsh, forthright persona – “I’d just end up with someone else who’d give me shit all the time.”
Of the 9 best picture nominees at the upcoming Academy Awards, Nebraska is the last to receive a release here in Australia. It’s therefore with a tinge of sadness that another “awards season” comes to a close. It’s now time to prepare for a myriad of reboots, remakes and sequels. Oh, and a bunch of stuff involving over-the-top action and comic book heroes. Brace yourself.
Review: Mandela: Long Walk To Freedom
- Details
- Written by Matthew Toomey
Directed by: | Justin Chadwick |
Written by: | William Nicholson |
Starring: | Idris Elba, Naomie Harris, Tony Kgoroge, Riaad Moosa, Zolani Mkiva, Simo Mogwaza |
Released: | February 6, 2014 |
Grade: | B+ |
The most common approach with a biopic is to focus on a small part of the subject’s life and cover it in sufficient detail. Lincoln covered the President’s attempts to abolish slavery in 1865. Capote recounted the events that led to the famed novel In Cold Blood in the early 1960s. The King’s Speech looked at how King George VI overcame his stutter on ascending the British throne in 1936.
Director Justin Chadwick (The Other Boleyn Girl) and Oscar nominated screenwriter William Nicholson (Shadowlands, Gladiator) have gone for something far broader with Mandela: Long Walk To Freedom. They’ve taken Nelson Mandela’s autobiography (a rather lengthy 630 pages) and tried to condense more than 50 years of his life (1942 to 1994) into just over two hours.
It works… kind of. If you were new to the Nelson Mandela story and were looking for a neat summary of his upbringing, his struggles and his achievements, you’ll find it here. Idris Elba (Pacific Rim, Thor), in a rare leading role for him, does a good job recreating Mandela’s speech and mannerisms. Naomie Harris (Skyfall) also makes her presence felt by stepping into the shoes of Winnie Mandela.
Unfortunately, the film can’t quite overcome the inevitable problems with trying to tell a long story in a short space of time. It feels like we’re rushing between events and there’s never enough time to “take stock” and absorb some of the key themes. If you were to compare it to last week’s 12 Years A Slave – a story also about rights and freedom – it’s easier to see where this film is lacking. The emotional impact isn’t as strong. Some of the dialogue is a bit cheesy too.
South African born producer Anant Singh became friends with Mandela not long after he was released from prison in 1990 and was granted to rights to the autobiography after it was first published in 1995. You’d think that studios would jump at the chance to bring this tale to the big screen but it’s taken almost two decades to get where we are today. Authenticity was of particular importance to Singh and so actual locations were used wherever possible. These included scenes in the courtroom at the Palace of Justice and also at the prison on Robben Island.
It’s been a busy awards season and Mandela: Long Walk To Freedom hasn’t quite generated the attention that its financiers would have hoped for. The film’s only Academy Award nomination is for best song – a piece entitled “Ordinary Love” which was written by U2 and appears at the start of the closing credits. It’ll face strong competition from Frozen’s “Let It Go” on Oscar night.
Review: Dallas Buyer's Club
- Details
- Written by Matthew Toomey
Directed by: | Jean-Marc Vallée |
Written by: | Craig Borten, Melisa Wallack |
Starring: | Matthew McConaughey, Jared Leto, Jennifer Garner, Denis O'Hare, Steve Zahn, Michael O'Neill |
Released: | February 13, 2014 |
Grade: | B+ |
When the Academy Award nominations were announced a few weeks ago, the one film that caught many pundits off guard was Dallas Buyer’s Club. It picked up 6 nods including best picture. Stars Matthew McConaughey and Jared Leto are the frontrunners (at least according to the bookies) in the categories of best actor and best supporting actor.
The film begins in 1985 and introduces us to a “blokey” guy by the name of Ron Woodroof (McConaughey). He works as an electrician, he moonlights as a rodeo cowboy, and he runs from people to whom he owes money. After a small workplace accident, Ron is taken to hospital and is given some shocking news from his doctors. His blood tested positive for HIV and he has roughly 30 days left to live.
That news sets the stage for what is quite an encompassing film. It’s trying to explore a lot of angles and it does a good job, as opposed to a great job. First and foremost, it’s providing a not-so-flattering portrayal of the Food and Drug Administration (FBA) authority. Ron was prepared to try any drug that might help, including those that hadn’t been properly tested in the United States, but the FDA put up road block after road block. They weren’t sympathetic to his plight.
It prompted Ron to establish the Dallas Buyer’s Club – an association for those who were HIV-positive. Membership was $400 a year and that entitled them to a regular supply of untested drugs secretly imported from overseas. Ron was able to circumvent the FDA’s rules because his customers weren’t directly buying drugs… they were buying club memberships.
Ron’s reasons for starting the Club were wholly self-motivated (he was trying to prolong his life and make some decent cash) but that started to change over time. He became friends with many of his customers, most of whom were homosexual, and it opened his eyes to a world he has always shunned. It’s here where Jared Leto gets his chance to impress as Ron’s transgender business partner.
Craig Borten originally wrote the screenplay for Dallas Buyer’s Club back in the early 1990s but it took two decades to secure the finance to get it into production. It’s hard to believe given the acclaim it’s now receiving. The director who stepped up to the plate is Canadian Jean-Marc Vallée – who I admired for his 2005 film C.R.A.Z.Y. and have followed ever since.
Three years ago, if you told me that Matthew McConaughey might win an Oscar, I’d have laughed. The guy was making crappy rom-coms including Failure To Launch, Fool’s Gold and Ghost Of Girlfriends Past. Things started to turn with The Lincoln Lawyer (released in mid-2011) and he’s built on that momentum ever since. He’s at his charismatic best in Dallas Buyer’s Club. He also dropped roughly 20kgs before taking on the roll thanks to a diet of egg whites, chicken and Diet Coke.
The movie gives off mixed messages at times. It looked to be demonising the FDA (for better or worse) but a few moments during the film suggested otherwise. The relevance of certain supporting characters (such as Jennifer Garner as Ron’s doctor) was also questionable. That said, it’s still a debate-generating film that’s worth your time and money.
Review: Last Vegas
- Details
- Written by Matthew Toomey
Directed by: | Jon Turtletaub |
Written by: | Dan Forgelman |
Starring: | Robert DeNiro, Michael Douglas, Morgan Freeman, Kevin Kline, Mary Steenburgen, Jerry Ferrara |
Released: | February 6, 2014 |
Grade: | B |
They’ve been best friends for 60 years but time is finally starting our four protagonists. Sam (Kline) has enrolled in a water aerobics class to try to get back into shape. Archie (Freeman) is recovering from a mild stroke and is dealing with his overprotective family. Paddy (DeNiro) has become a depressed couch potato following the death of his wife. Billy (Douglas) is worried about dying alone and has decided to take the plunge and marry someone less than half his age.
What better way of getting over their problems… than spending a wild weekend in Las Vegas! They can dance, play blackjack, drink martinis, judge swimsuit competitions, get laid, and generally have a good time. It’s designed to be an impromptu bachelor party for Billy before he finally ties the knot.
These are shallow characters. They’re loveable/sleazy (take your pick) and they all have some kind of magic epiphany over the course of the weekend that has them re-evaluating their lives. It’s a stretch. We never really get to know them. There are problems with the ending too. Writer Dan Fogelman (Crazy Stupid Love, The Trip) has created such a convoluted scenario that it’s really hard to come up with a plausible conclusion where everyone is “smelling like roses”.
That’s not to say that the film isn’t entertaining. Robert DeNiro, Michael Douglas, Morgan Freeman and Kevin Kline – all Academy Award winning actors – share the jokes around and have a good sense of comedic timing. They generally poke fun at themselves (describing the weekend as the “first bachelor party covered by Medicare”) but they also find time to mock those a little younger.
It's far from perfect but there's a layer of sentimentality that makes Last Vegas easier to digest. These guys reflect back on their lives and the enduring power of friendship. There are no Earth-shattering revelations but it’ll still win over the majority of cinema-goers. That’s evidenced from the film’s box-office take thus far – more than $120m internationally on a budget of just $28m (me thinks our leading men didn’t get paid huge dollars).
Review: Blue Is The Warmest Colour
- Details
- Written by Matthew Toomey
Directed by: | Abdellatif Kechiche |
Written by: | Abdellatif Kechiche, Ghalia Lacroix |
Starring: | Léa Seydoux, Adèle Exarchopoulos, Salim Kechiouche, Aurélien Recoing, Catherine Salée |
Released: | February 13, 2014 |
Grade: | B+ |
It’s Valentine’s Day this week and here in Australia there are a few “romantic” options being offered in cinemas. I’ve been won over by my fair share of romantic comedies/dramas because of quality casting but that said, it’s hard to think of another genre that so often falls back on overused clichés and predictable plot points (well, aside from horror films).
Some films pair a nice girl with a bad boy (or vice-versa) and prove that opposites attract. Others have two people who don’t realise they’re in love (despite the fact it’s painfully obvious to everyone else in the movie… and in the cinema). Perhaps the one that frustrates me most is where the two characters fall in love, have a stupid misunderstanding, and then end up back together.
I make this reference so as to highlight that Blue Is The Warmest Colour is something different. If you were to describe it in a single sentence, you’d say it’s a French coming-of-age tale that centres on a 17-year-old high school student named Adele who falls in love for the first time. Such a simple explanation wouldn’t do the film justice, however. This is an intriguing, three-hour character study that requires you to observe and analyse.
In the same way that I admired Michelle Williams in Take This Waltz (released back in 2011), I was drawn to Adele’s character because of her insecure, emotional disposition. She’s a smart young woman. No doubt about that. She loves to read and hopes to be a teacher one day. On the flip side though, Adele is shy, unsure of herself. She’s quiet, she’s constantly fiddles with her hair, and she’s seemingly unaware of her own beauty.
Confused as to what she’s looking for romantically, Adele finds the answer with a “love at first sight” kind of encounter on a busy street. The object of her affection is an older woman named Emma (Seydoux) who stands out from the crowd with her distinctive blue hair. It’s not long before the pair become inseparable.
Rather than lead us by the hand to a predetermined destination, this is a film that asks us to stand back and observe. What do you think of this couple? Do they belong together? With next-to-no experience when it comes to relationships, has Adele attached herself too strongly? What of Emma? Is she attracted solely to Adele because she’s young and good looking… or is there something deeper?
Blue Is The Warmest Colour has taken an up and down journey since it premiered at the Cannes Film Festival last May. The Festival jury (which included Steven Spielberg, Ang Lee, Nicole Kidman and Christoph Waltz) and the International Federation of Film Critics both gave the film their top prize. It was just the start of the acclaim. Critics in New York and Los Angeles named it the year’s best foreign language film and it’s nominated in the upcoming BAFTAs in the same category.
Despite the critical acclaim, the film has shrouded in controversy because of the actions of director Abdellatif Kechiche. Crew members claim they were subject to harassment and were not adequately paid for their work. Stars Adèle Exarchopoulos and Léa Seydoux stated that Kechiche didn’t meet any lesbians or do any research prior to the shoot. New York Times critic Manohla Dargis expressed concerns about the film’s ten-minute sex scene which she noted “feels far more about Mr Kechiche’s desires than anything else.”
If nothing else, the film will provide some good conversation starters. Filmmakers are often pandering to audiences with nice, happy, feel-good moments – as unrealistic as they may be. I’ve seen plenty of romantic comedies where I can’t believe the couple end up together in the end. To come back to this movie… is the inclusion of a lengthy, gratuitous sex scene between two women any different? Is it exploitive? Or is it just another way to shock/titillate audiences?
While three hours is a little too long to be investing in this story, Blue Is The Warmest Colour is film I won’t be forgetting any time soon.