Reviews
Review: The Three Musketeers: D'Artagnan
- Details
- Written by Matthew Toomey
Directed by: | Martin Bourboulon |
Written by: | Matthieu Delaporte, Alexandre de La Patellière |
Starring: | François Civil, Vincent Cassel, Romain Duris, Pio Marmaï, Eva Green, Lyna Khoudri, Louis Garrel, Vicky Krieps, Jacob Fortune-Lloyd |
Released: | May 16, 2024 |
Grade: | B |
Alexandre Dumas’ 1844 novel has been translated for cinema many times, but this is the first French adaptation since the not-so-well-reviewed Revenge of the Musketeers hit theatres in 1994. Just a teenager at the time, Martin Bourboulon can remember being taken on set by his father, Frederic, who served as the film’s producer. There’s a sense of serendipity at play here as Martin, who followed his dad into the industry, is now directing his own big screen interpretation of The Three Musketeers.
“Big” is the right word to use. The budget was €72 million (huge for a French flick), the shoot took 150 days, and there are two movies in all (both roughly 120 minutes each). French audiences had to wait nine months between instalments but here in Australia, the gap is much narrower. Hot off its showing at the French Film Festival, The Three Musketeers: D'Artagnan gets its turn in cinemas this week with The Three Musketeers: Milady arriving next month on June 6.
Previous adaptations have emphasised the novel’s comedic elements (such as the 1993 American version starring Chris O’Donnell) but here, the two-man writing team have gone with a heavier, Game of Thrones-type vibe. It’s still set in the 17th Century, but they’ve taken the opportunity to look at Dumas’ work through a more current day, progressive lens. As examples, one of the Musketeers is bisexual, and they’re considerably more respectful of women.
For those unfamiliar with the material, it’s centred on the young D'Artagnan (Civil) who, driven by a desire to serve and protect the king, befriends three influential musketeers and falls under their tutelage. He’s immediately caught up in a conspiracy involving murder and manipulation, and so the expanded quartet go on a mission to find out who’s responsible. One person in their sights is the maleficent Milady de Winter (Green) who is as cunning as she is seductive.
The story isn’t the easiest to follow (lots of characters and subplots) and while parts of the translation are confusing (the politics), there’s still a lot to like. In the same vein as The Lord of the Rings, there’s something appealing about a swashbuckling epic with a booming film score set across a variety of cool locations with swords, horses, and spirited battles. The production values are great! Led by star François Civil (Love at Second Sight), the cast are a worthy fit for their respective characters and give us clear heroes to cheer for, and villains to root against.
You get a sense the juicier stuff is being saved for the second film but The Three Musketeers: D'Artagnan still stands on its own two feet. Fun, interesting, and engaging.
Review: Monster
- Details
- Written by Matthew Toomey
Directed by: | Hirokazu Kore-eda |
Written by: | Yuji Sakamoto |
Starring: | Sakura Andō, Eita Nagayama, Sōya Kurokawa, Hinata Hiiragi, Yūko Tanaka, Mitsuki Takahata |
Released: | May 9, 2024 |
Grade: | A- |
When a topical subject matter is talked about on news sites and social media, there’s no shortage of individuals passionately weighing in with their thoughts. It’s easy to forget that each person’s view is shaped by perspective. Their opinions are influenced by their upbringing, their family/friends, their personality, their politics, and the level of background information they have about the subject.
This theme is delicately explored in Monster, the latest feature from acclaimed Palme d’Or winning Japanese director Hirokazu Kore-eda (Shoplifters). It’s centred on Minato (Kurokawa), an 11-year-old boy who lives with his single mother (Andō) in the small Japanese city of Suwa. He’s a relatively quiet kid whose best friend is a fellow fifth grade student, Yori (Hiiragi).
With a runtime of just over two hours, Monster is split into three distinct acts. Minato starts behaving oddly and the film delves into the reasons from a trio of viewpoints – his concerned mother who can’t understand what’s going on, his conflicted teacher (Nagayama) who isn’t sure how to react, and finally, the perspective of Minato himself. As each layer is pulled back, another equally interesting plot point is revealed. It’s easy to see why writer Yuji Sakamoto won best screenplay at last year’s Cannes Film Festival.
This is an intriguing character study from start to finish. The whole cast pull their weight and through their performances, we understand their motivations as they navigate their way through a complex situation (I don’t want to give too much away). Misinformation leads to confusion which leads to poor decision making. As the audience, we can reflect on which characters (if any) deserve a harsher judgement, and if any of the outbursts could have been avoided.
Given the same story is told three times, this could easily have become ho-hum but Kore-eda keeps things fresh and interesting by varying the cinematography and focal points. It’s like a colourful jigsaw puzzle where we can see the individual pieces but can’t see the “bigger picture” until most of the pieces are placed in the correct position. The film’s final scene also creates discussion points to think/chat about afterwards.
With a contemplative music score from Academy Award winning composer Ryuichi Sakamoto (The Last Emperor), Monster continues the recent trend of great foreign language films getting a release in Australian cinemas.
Review: The Fall Guy
- Details
- Written by Matthew Toomey
Directed by: | David Leitch |
Written by: | Drew Pearce |
Starring: | Ryan Gosling, Emily Blunt, Aaron Taylor-Johnson, Winston Duke, Hannah Waddingham, Stephanie Hsu |
Released: | April 24, 2024 |
Grade: | C |
After a successful 6-year stretch, the career of stuntman Colt Seavers (Gosling) ended abruptly after a stunt-gone-wrong led to a serious back injury. He now lives alone and works as a parking valet for a run-down Mexican restaurant. That’s about to change. After getting the call from a powerful executive producer (Waddingham), a rejuvenated Colt is flown to Sydney to work on a big-budget science-fiction flick about a human falling in love with an alien (it looks terrible). A colleague (Duke) sums it up best – “it’s time for you to start rolling cars again instead of parking them.”
The Fall Guy is an odd film. It’s a mishmash of genres that writer Drew Pearce (Iron Man 3) struggles to weave together. There’s a romantic, “tortured souls” connection between Colt and the film’s director, Jody Moreno (Blunt), but it’s a rocky one given they had a falling out after Colt’s accident. There’s a mystery component when the film’s A-list star, Tom Ryder (Taylor-Johnson), gets involved with the criminal underworld and goes missing during the shoot. There’s a strong comedic flavour as characters talk flippantly and light-heartedly despite the gravity of the situation. The film also serves as a tribute to stuntpeople and their perceived lack of recognition (no Oscars for them) when it comes to promotion and awards.
I’ll cut to the chase and say this is one of the worst screenplays served up this year. This could have been quite funny but every attempt at humour is over-scripted and uninspired. Colt and Jody discuss the merits of split screen while we, as the audience, see them talking in split screen. That's the best they could think of? There’s a moment on set where Jody, despite wanting to keep things “profesh”, lectures Colt in front of everyone about how the film’s plot is a metaphor for their own fractured romantic past. These scenes drag on too long, the dialogue is forgettable, and they induce cringe as opposed to laughs.
The repetitively annoying nature of certain material also wears thin quickly. How many times did we need to hear about “spicy margaritas” and “bad decisions”? What’s the point of continually namedropping films like The Fast & The Furious and The Last of the Mohicans? I’m a fan of the KISS song “I Was Made For Lovin’ You” but why did it have to be used so often? If crafting a lengthy fight sequence to take place on the Sydney Harbour Bridge, why not write something that better showcases stunt folk as opposed to relying on obvious visual effects? Why cast recent Oscar nominee Stephanie Hsu (Everything Everywhere All at Once) if giving her nothing meaningful to do?
The Fall Guy will tick boxes to promote Australian tourism (there’s even a scene on the steps of the Sydney Opera House) but if you’re looking for a fun, entertaining way to spend two hours… this ain’t it.
Review: Fremont
- Details
- Written by Matthew Toomey
Directed by: | Babak Jalali |
Written by: | Babak Jalali, Carolina Cavalli |
Starring: | Anaita Wali Zada, Gregg Turkington, Jeremy Allen White |
Released: | May 2, 2024 |
Grade: | A- |
The inspiration for Iranian-British filmmaker Babak Jalali (Radio Dreams) came from the real-life stories of Afghan refugees living in the San Francisco Bay Area. These people had risked their lives working as translators for American soldiers during the war against the Taliban in Afghanistan and in return, they were granted safe passage to the United States. From there however, they had been largely forgotten about and left to fend for themselves.
Jalali’s film is centred on the fictional Donya, beautifully played by newcomer Anaita Wali Zada in her first acting role. She’s a former Afghan translator who emigrated to California eight months ago and now works in a Chinese fortune cookie production factory in the city of Fremont. It’s a lonely existence. She resides in a tiny apartment (her bedroom only has room for a single bed), lives off a meagre income, and has no family to spend time with (they’re all back in Afghanistan). Her only friend is a chatty work colleague, and they’ll often exchange text messages of an evening.
We’ve all got a different sense of humour but if you like your comedies dark and dry, Fremont is for you! The inner workings of the fortune cookie company are hilarious as Donya interacts with a semi-deluded boss, an elderly lady who can barely use a computer, and a broken coffee machine. Laughs are also drawn from her appointments with an offbeat, book-loving therapist (Turkington) who reluctantly prescribes sleeping pills to help with her insomnia. Even the innocuous dinner scenes in a rundown restaurant (she’s the only customer) deserve a shout out.
These chuckles are balanced seamlessly with the more dramatic themes of loneliness and self-worth. It is sometimes hard to “get a read” on Donya given her emotionless expressions but as the film progresses, we get a better sense of her character’s mental health. It really hits home in the final half-hour as she meets a mechanic, delicately played by recent Emmy winner Jeremy Allen White (The Bear), who is in similar need of conversation and companionship. It has been a while since I was cheering so strongly for two characters to get together – they just need to harness the courage and open up.
At the recent Independent Spirit Awards, Fremont won the John Cassavetes Award which goes to the year’s best film with a budget of less than $1 million. Shot in distinctive black and white, Fremont is a funny, big-hearted reminder that you don’t need big dollars to make a great movie.
Review: The Teacher's Lounge
- Details
- Written by Matthew Toomey
Directed by: | İlker Çatak |
Written by: | İlker Çatak, Johannes Duncker |
Starring: | Leonie Benesch, Leonard Stettnisch, Eva Löbau, Michael Klammer; Rafael Stachowiak, Sarah Bauerett |
Released: | April 25, 2024 |
Grade: | A- |
Of the five nominees for best international feature at this year’s Academy Awards, The Teacher’s Lounge is the last to be made available to Australian audiences. Made in Germany, it has resonated with audiences on the festival circuit since its premiere in Berlin over a year ago and took home five German Film Awards including best picture, best director, and best actress. The acclaim is justified.
It’s an intricate, complicated story which takes place entirely within the walls of a school. Money, stationery, and other items have gone missing, and a group of teachers are attempting to identify the students responsible. It reaches a point where class captains are being interrogated for potential leads, and random wallet inspections take place during lessons. One of the 7th grade teachers, Carla Nowak (Benesch), is uncomfortable with the school’s invasive response to the matter and expresses her concerns.
Thinking that perhaps an adult may be the culprit, Carla uses her laptop camera to spy on teachers in the staff room. It records the arm of a person taking money from inside a jacket pocket on Carla’s desk. They’re identified as a long-serving administrative officer, Ms Kuhn (Löbau), who strongly refutes the accusation but after a heated confrontation involving the school’s principal, she is placed on leave pending a formal investigation. Adding to the delicacy of the situation is that the accused has a son, Oskar, who attends the school and is in Carla’s class.
The Teacher’s Lounge offers much to think about in terms of information and who should be entitled to it. Carla and the headmaster would prefer to keep things quiet pending the investigation but given Ms Kuhn is a much-admired member of the community, “Chinese whispers” start spreading in online group chats and frustrations are vented at a parent-teacher evening. It’s a powerful scene as we watch Carla defend the school’s actions with one hand metaphorically tied behind her back. There’s not much she can say.
Another worthy issue to reflect upon are the reputational connections between a parent and their child. With his mum suspected of wrongdoing, Oskar is ostracised by fellow students, and his persona and grades take a negative shift. This poses further questions of the audience around the subjects of regret and forgiveness as Carla starts to rethink her approach. She may have firm proof of Ms Kuhn stealing money but if it’s the child who suffers, is it the right outcome? Adding further drama are teachers upset with Carla that she would use her laptop to spy in the first place.
Featuring a slew of authentic performances and realistic conversations, I can now see why The Teacher’s Lounge has resonated so powerfully.
Review: The Taste of Things
- Details
- Written by Matthew Toomey
Directed by: | Trần Anh Hùng |
Written by: | Trần Anh Hùng |
Starring: | Juliette Binoche, Benoît Magimel, Emmanuel Salinger, Patrick d'Assumçao, Galatea Bellugi, Jan Hammenecker |
Released: | May 2, 2024 |
Grade: | A- |
Whether it be two Italian brothers running a struggling restaurant (Big Night), a guy driving across America with a Cuban food truck (Chef), or a talking rat who dreams of becoming a chef (Ratatouille), there’s something about “food movies” that whets the appetite and lures audiences in. You may not be able to smell and taste what appears on screen, but the sights and sounds of the succulent dishes create a near-equal sense of fulfillment.
The Taste of Things was submitted as France’s entry in the best international feature film category of this year’s Academy Awards. That caused a ruckus within cinematic circles given its submission ahead of the Palme d’Or winning Anatomy of a Fall. More fuel was added to the fire when The Taste of Things ultimately missed out on a nomination while Anatomy earned nods for best screenplay (which it won), best director, and best picture.
While most (including me) would agree Anatomy of a Fall is the superior flick, The Taste of Things is still a high-quality romantic drama which audiences should embrace. It’s a late 19th Century tale set on a French estate. Dodin (Magimel) owns the beautiful residence while Eugénie (Binoche) has served as his in-house cook for roughly two decades. What began as a simple professional relationship has now become a deeper connection driven by love and admiration.
I admired the approach of Vietnamese-born filmmaker Trần Anh Hùng (The Scent of Green Papaya) who serves as both writer and director. We’ve seen plenty of movies where two characters express their love physically (kissing, sex) or through heartfelt conversation. In this case, Dodin and Eugénie get the message across through the power of food. They’ll spend hours in the well-stocked kitchen using the freshest of ingredients to cook up mouth-watering dishes for each other. Dialogue is used sparingly as it’s the food which does the talking.
It’s a great role for both Benoît Magimel (The Piano Teacher) and Oscar winner Juliette Binoche (The English Patient) who fit the characters beautifully. Void of cliches and artificial tension, it’s just nice to watch the day-to-day actions of two people who love life, food, and each other. Several sequences will leave you smiling and, in seeing the positive side of the human condition, it provides an injection of “feel good” which sticks with you on leaving the cinema.