Reviews

Directed by: James Cameron
Written by: James Cameron, Rick Jaffa, Amanda Silver, Josh Friedman, Shane Salerno
Starring: Sam Worthington, Zoe Saldaña, Sigourney Weaver, Stephen Lang, Kate Winslet, Cliff Curtis, Jack Champion
Released: December 15, 2022
Grade: B+

Avatar: The Way of Water

In terms of filmmaking, there is very little, if anything, that James Cameron has left to prove.  He will go down in history as one of the most successful directors of all time.  His early years featured classics such as Aliens, The Abyss, and the first two Terminator movies.  In 1997, Titanic won a record 11 Academy Awards (the record still stands) and became the highest grossing movie of all time in the United States.  That benchmark stood for 12 years until Cameron’s very next film, Avatar, bettered Titanic’s domestic gross in just 47 days and would go on to make a phenomenal $2.75 billion at the global box-office.

Having waited over a decade, Cameron finally takes audiences back to the world of Pandora for another adventure involving our beloved blue characters.  It’s epic in terms of cost ($350-$400 million), epic in terms of duration (193 minutes), and epic in terms of technological advancement.  The film has been shot to make the most of 3D cinema (which we haven’t seen much of in recent years) and certain action scenes utilise the smoother, but seldom used, 48 frames per second rate as opposed to the traditional 24.

Avatar: The Way of Water provides an incredible spectacle.  The visuals make you think that every other action flick of the past decade was made in the 1950s.  It’s head-scratching that Cameron can create such a stunningly beautiful world with bright, clear, easy-to-follow battles (the sound effects are great too) while all other directors keep churning out the same dark, grainy, repetitive-looking stuff.  Maybe it’s a budget thing?  Maybe Cameron is simply in a league of his own?

I’m not as enthusiastic when it comes to narrative.  I was never bored in Avatar: The Way of Water but the five-person writing team take few chances and go down a familiar, well-worth path.  I feel like I’ve seen this type of action story 10,000 times now – one where people make reckless decisions and put their lives in danger because nothing is more important than “family” and keeping them safe.  Given the 68-year-old Cameron has three more sequels planned, it could give The Fast and The Furious franchise a run for its money in who pushes the family theme hardest. 

To provide a quick synopsis, the Earth is still dying and a small group of well-armed human soldiers are hoping to “pacify” the Na’vi locals on Pandora and take over the planet as their own.  Their latest scheme is to adopt Na’vi avatars, sneak through local defences, and take down Jake Sully (Worthington), the heroic human-turned-Na’vi who has become a thorn in their side.  In addition to Jake, the “good guy” side includes his partner (Saldaña), their four kids, a new clan of people, a teenager named “Spider” (Champion), and a bunch of super-smart fish.  Some subplots are resolved whilst others will carry over into future movies.

Considering all other studios have run for the hills and are putting up nothing against it (last week’s box-office in the U.S. was the worst in 11 months), Avatar: The Way of Water will be one of this year’s biggest hits.  See it on the biggest screen you can find.  It’s review-proof.

Directed by: Matthew Warchus
Written by: Dennis Kelly
Starring: Alisha Weir, Lashana Lynch, Stephen Graham, Andrea Riseborough, Emma Thompson, Sindhu Vee
Released: December 8, 2022
Grade: B+

Matilda the Musical

There is no doubt (warning: there may be doubt) that Matilda the Musical is one of the best stage shows of the 21st Century.  Roald Dahl’s 1988 novel was already terrific… but Dennis Kelly (book) and Tim Minchin (music and lyrics) transformed it into a musical which is just as memorable.  It’s humorous, it’s emotional, and it’s not afraid to get really dark (a rarity when it comes to family-oriented stuff).  It boasts a fantastic, well-crafted music score and, through performances across the world, has allowed a plethora of young actors to showcase their rising talents.

It was always a matter of when, not if, the show would be adapted for the big screen.  It has been spruiked since 2013 and after years of waiting, director Matthew Warchus (also responsible for the stage musical) has finally completed what fans have been waiting for.  It’s not a like-for-like adaptation however.  A few changes have been made to trim roughly 20 minutes and have it sneak in under the two hour mark (for the benefit of those with shorter attention spans).

If you’re new to the material, it’s the tale of super smart young girl named Matilda who is the product of two selfish, ignorant, rotten parents.  Unable to find proper adult guidance at home, two kind people fill the gap – a knowledgeable librarian who provides wonderful books to read, and a softly-spoken schoolteacher who can easily detect Matilda’s intelligence.  In addition to the parents, there’s one more villain threatening to upend Matilda’s life – the nasty, power-hungry school headmaster who thinks of children like scum.

I’m a fan of Matthew Warchus (Pride) but the direction here is a little scrappy and haphazard.  When compared to some of the great modern day movie musicals (e.g. Moulin Rouge, Chicago, La La Land) you’ll realise the elaborate musical numbers don’t flow smoothly.  A little magic has been lost in the editing room with the uneven mix of close-ups and long shots.  One exception is the “School Song” which comes across very well.

Despite those qualms, it’s hard not to be won over by this movie given the strength of the source material.  The songs are so damn good!  Warchus has also struck gold in finding 13-year-old star Alisha Weir who has a fantastic voice and the perfect look for the title role.  She beat out thousands of others as part of a lengthy audition process.  Emma Thompson continues her sensational year (hot on the heels of Good Luck to You, Leo Grande) and creates an ideal can’t-wait-till-she-gets-what-she-deserves villain in headmaster Miss Trunchbull.

It’s hard to match the joy and energy that comes from a live performance and while this adaption falls a touch short, it’s still heaps of fun.

Directed by: Gracie Otto
Written by: Krew Boylan
Starring: Krew Boylan, Daniel Webber, Rose Byrne, Celeste Barber, Bobby Cannavale, Thomas Campbell
Released: November 24, 2022
Grade: B+

Seriously Red

The phrase “imitation is the sincerest form of flattery” is one that’s stuck with me through life.  Who we become is often shaped by those we admire.  Some go a few steps further and, through careful mimicry, make a living from impersonating others.  Actors (if lucky) can earn big bucks and a few awards by portraying real-life people on stage and screen.  It can even reach a point over time where reality blends with artistic interpretation.  My mum grew up listening to the songs of the actual Frankie Valli whereas I was introduced to his music and his story thanks via an actor portraying him in the smash hit Broadway musical Jersey Boys.  Which “version” will permeate best with future generations?

 Seriously Red is a fictitious Australian comedy-drama centred on a troop of music impersonators who travel across the country performing in front of small crowds.  There’s Elvis Presley, Kenny Rogers, Neil Diamond, and several more.  They’re no superstars but they love what they do and they seem to make enough cash to pay bills and buy costumes.  Their latest recruit is Red, a Dolly Parton devotee who has given up on her spirit-crushing bank job and found an enjoying, engaging career which offers more fulfilment.

Director Gracie Otto (The Last Impresario) and writer Krew Boylan, who also stars in the lead role of Red, have done a terrific job in exploring this intriguing world.  It’s never forcing a particular viewpoint on the audience but it asks us to think and form an opinion about these characters.  Should we look at them as failed/misguided artists who mimic others because they lack talent and can’t find their own true identity?  Or should we look at them as gifted performers who bring a little light to towns across rural Australia by allowing customers to relive iconic musical moments from yesteryear?

Boylan, in her capacity as a writer, is particularly skilled when it comes to creating interesting supporting characters.  You’ll have fun trying to get inside the head of the Kenny Rogers imitator, wonderful played by Daniel Webber (Billy the Kid), who takes on the persona 24-7.  An almost unrecognisable Rose Byrne (Damages) is similarly good as an Elvis Presley knock-off who uses it as an opportunity to explore her sexuality.  The best of the comedic material goes to Jean Kittson (Let the Blood Run Free) who steals any scene she’s involved with as Red’s loving but concerned mother.

Seriously Red is one of the best Australian movies of 2022.  It offers dark, unexpected laughs (Red’s drunken antics at a work party) which are nicely balanced against the film’s dramatic core.  When characters open up in the final act and let us see behind their facades, you’re reminded that first impressions aren’t always accurate. 

Directed by: Jérôme Salle
Written by: Jérôme Salle, Caryl Ferey
Starring: Gilles Lellouche, Joanna Kulig, Louis-Do de Lencquesain, Michael Gor, Aleksey Gorbunov, Elisa Lasowski
Released: December 1, 2022
Grade: B

Kompromat

The word has been used in Russia for several decades but in 2017, “kompromat” made its way into the English database of Dictionary.com.  It is defined as “compromising and incriminating material that is sometimes forged or fabricated, used to sabotage or discredit a political opponent or public figure.”  It came to prominence within the media when allegations emerged that Russian officials had gathered “kompromat” on President Donald Trump which could be used against him.

This new French drama is the tale of an Alliance française director, Mathieu Roussel (Lellouche), who has spent several months posted to the Siberian region of Russia along with his wife and young daughter.  Mathieu doesn’t know precisely why (there’s several possibilities) but he’s annoyed someone within Russia’s powerful Federal Security Service (FSB) who have fabricated evidence to charge him with child abuse and accessing child pornography.

Facing a 15-year stint in prison, a small group of people will do their best to get Mathieu out of the country before the trial.  These include his no-nonsense defence lawyer, a Russian co-worker (Kulig), and officials at the French embassy in Moscow.  On his tail are a group of nasty looking FSB folk who travel across the country in pursuit of their target after skipping his house arrest.

The film is clunky in the way in which it portrays Mathieu.  There’s an early scene where he hosts Russian officials at a French ballet which includes homoerotic themes.  Suffice to say the officials don’t take it well.  On the other hand, we see him being quite resourceful as he sneaks around the country avoiding detection.  It’s hard to believe a French teacher could be so blind to basic Russian culture while also having the skills of Jason Bourne.

There’s still much to take away from this however and the fact it’s based on actual events is high on that list.  It highlights the corruption that exists within the Russian government and the ways they can use the police, the media, and the judicial system to silence those who don’t share their views.  It also reminds us that not everyone in Russia supports the controlling government and, through the character of Svetlana, we learn there are people willing to risk their own lives in defiance.

Those looking to know more about the subject may be interested in Yoann Barbereau’s memoir, Escape from Siberia: My Epic Journey to Freedom, which delves more into the true story behind Kompromat.  While this film is rough around the edges, it’s a yarn deserving the full big screen treatment.

Directed by: Romuald Boulanger
Written by: Romuald Boulanger
Starring: Mel Gibson, William Moseley, Alia Seror-O’Neill, Paul Spera, Nadia Farès, Kevin Dillon
Released: November 17, 2022
Grade: B

On the Line

Elvis Cooney (Gibson) has forged a long, successful, colourful career within radio industry.  He currently has the midnight shift at a high-rating station in Los Angeles and his brand is to be controversial and “tell it like it is”.  A major part of his segment is talkback where callers cathartically open-up about their problems and Elvis responds with blunt, succinct advice.  Helping produce the show are Mary (Seror-O’Neill), an experienced operator who screen calls, and Dylan (Moseley), an intern on his first day at the station.

The above is covered is a short, succinct introduction before On the Line gets to its main hook.  A man named Gary calls through, is put live on air, and tells listeners that he has kidnapped Elvis’s wife and daughter.  His motives are linked to the mistreatment of his girlfriend who formally worked at the radio station.  Elvis initially thinks it is a sick prank but it doesn’t take long for Gary to prove his seriousness and put forward his list of equally serious demands.

I’m the first to admit this doesn’t always make sense… but French writer-director Romuald Boulanger did enough to keep me engaged and interested in the characters’ fate.  It moves at a swift pace, it doesn’t muck around with unnecessary subplots, and Mel Gibson creates an interesting antihero with his lead performance.  He’s not the most likeable person (illustrated by an early scene where he plays an over-the-top joke on the intern) but you’ll cheer for him nevertheless as he tries to outsmart the aggrieved Gary.

There’s another reason I enjoyed the film but it’s hard to articulate as it relates to the finale.  Not everyone will be a fan but it worked for me.  Let’s just leave it at that and hopefully my cryptic comment will make sense to those who see the film.  The trailers and marketing material give On the Line a trashy B-grade vibe and while that’s true in places, it’s also an entertaining action-thriller.  Grab some popcorn and enjoy.

Directed by: Mark Mylod
Written by: Seth Reiss, Will Tracy
Starring: Ralph Fiennes, Anya Taylor-Joy, Nicholas Hoult, Hong Chau, Janet McTeer, John Leguizamo, Reed Birney, Judith Light, Paul Adelstein
Released: November 24, 2022
Grade: B+

The Menu

There’s an early scene in The Menu where head chef, Julian Slowik (Fiennes), comes out from the kitchen and addresses the customers in his exclusive 12-seat restaurant.  He talks about how bread has existed for 12,000 years, is one of the simplest foods imaginable (flour plus water), and has become a staple in poorer communities.  He then serves up a “breadless bread plate” – tasty dips with nothing else.  His rationale?  Bread is food for the “common man” and the wealthy, successful, hoity-toity folk in the room don’t meet that description.

This sequence helps articulate what’s on offer in this new film from director Mark Mylod (Game of Thrones, Succession).  Movies about food tend to be heartfelt and entertaining (Big Night, The Lunchbox, Ratatouille) but The Menu has been crafted as a dark, unsettling comedy where you’re never quite sure what will happen next.  Each guest, personally selected by Slowik, has stumped up a farcical $1,250 for the 4+ hour degustation but it’s not long before the meals become secondary to the “experience”.

 The Menu is the cinematic equivalent of a “hot mess”.  It’s engrossing and hilarious while also being chaotic and disjointed.  To focus on its weaker points… it’s very on-the-nose with its messaging and doesn’t give enough attention to its many supporting characters.  Tony Award winners Judith Light and Reed Birney play a long-married couple but, aside from a small plot reveal around the half-way mark, we don’t know enough about them to care.  I’d also argue the finale doesn’t pack a particularly strong punch.

I still had lots of fun though!  Ralph Fiennes (The Grand Budapest Hotel) is sensational as the playful/insane chef, Nicholas Hoult (About a Boy) is excellent as an increasingly selfish foody, and Hong Chau (Downsizing) steals a bunch of scenes as the restaurant’s disciplined captain.  There are many random, laugh-out-loud moments which will appeal those with warped comedic tastes.  These vary from the nonchalant actions of staff (like the sommelier) as things go crazy… to the written descriptions of each dish which are provided on screen (the last one is a cracker).

Mark Mylod doesn’t want to go unnoticed and adds an interesting directorial stamp.  A great example is the quick transitions between conversations as the camera seamlessly moves around the restaurant’s dining area.  The sudden clapping of hands by the kitchen staff, combined with a perfectly timed edit, provide a jolt to those within the film… and also to those watching the film.

A great movie to debate and dissect with friends, The Menu is worth making time for.