Reviews

Directed by: Marc Forster
Written by: David Magee
Starring: Tom Hanks, Mariana Treviño, Rachel Keller, Manuel Garcia-Rulfo, Cameron Britton, Mike Birbiglia
Released: January 1, 2023
Grade: B-

A Man Called Otto

I enjoyed the Oscar-nominated 2015 Swedish film upon which this is based, but the first thought which came to mind on seeing A Man Called Otto was that of Clint Eastwood’s lead performance in the 2008 drama Gran Torino.  In that film, we saw Eastwood play an old, widowed, racist man who sits on his front porch, growls at people walking past, complains about anything, and generally hates the world.

Tom Hanks doesn’t bring the same level of racism to his character here but, for those who’ve seen Gran Torino, you should know the type of person I’m about to describe.  Otto (Hanks), to use the words of his neighbours, is a “nasty, bitter old man”.  We often talk about optimistic people who see the glass as half full and pessimistic people who see it as half empty.  Well, I’d say Otto is the kind of person who would pour the contents of the glass on the floor and then remark that it’s fully empty.

You name it… he finds it annoying.  He buys 5-feet of cheap rope at the hardware store and then complains because he’s charged for 6-feet (the price is by the yard).  He mumbles about folks in his street putting the wrong trash in recycling bins.  He even gets cranky at his own work retirement party – a moment you’d think he would enjoy.  He hasn’t always been this way and a series of flashbacks help fill in the gaps as to why he’s so miserable.  This includes the death of his wife six months earlier which added to his isolation and loneliness.

As you might expect, A Man Called Otto is intended to be a feel-good flick where other characters finally crack Otto’s tough veneer and discover that he’s actually a nice guy with a big heart.  The one who does this best is Marisol (Treviño) an extroverted, Mexican-born woman who has just moved into the neighbourhood with her family.  She doesn’t like taking “no” for an answer and is quick to impose herself in Otto’s life.

Through his film production company, Tom Hanks snapped up the rights for an English language remake of the Swedish original (A Man Called Ove) and while I acknowledge its potential, I’m not convinced Hanks was the right fit for the lead role.  Perhaps he’s a victim of his own success but after decades of playing nice guys, I didn’t fully buy into his character.  I’ve met my fair share of grizzly, annoying people and Otto’s persona is a one-dimensional “act” as opposed to something more genuine.

Other elements also feel less authentic when compared to the earlier movie.  The film can’t quite find the right balance between seriousness and humour when showing Otto’s repeated suicide attempts.  They’re awkward and don’t fit with the broader, family-friendly tone.  Key plot points also feel overplayed such as the reaction of onlookers as Otto rescue a man who falls off a train platform.

All of that said, there are moments, particularly in the second half, which do work and will leave audiences feeling warm and fuzzy.  The scenes involving Hanks and Mexican actress Mariana Treviño are the film’s best and, through their polar-opposite personalities, we are reminded of the importance of human connections and that it’s never too late to be making new friends.

A Man Called Otto is contrived but it will still win many people over.

You can read my chat with star Mariana Treviño by clicking here.

Directed by: Martin McDonagh
Written by: Martin McDonagh
Starring: Colin Farrell, Brendan Gleeson, Kerry Condon, Barry Keoghan, Pat Shortt, Jon Kenny
Released: December 26, 2022
Grade: A

The Banshees of Inisherin

Writer-director Martin McDonagh is upfront about where his stories are set.  His plays include The Beauty Queen of Leenane, The Lieutenant of Inishmore, and a Behanding in Spokane.  His films include In Bruges, Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri, and now, The Banshees of Inisherin.  McDonagh’s knack for interesting titles (complete with locations) is matched by his ability to create dark, twisting narratives and complex, intriguing characters.  He’s one of the best filmmakers working today.

The Banshees of Inisherin is set on a small Irish island in the year 1923.  The weather is cold, the terrain is rugged, and folks make ends meet by working the land.  It’s also the kind of place where everybody knows everybody.  They go about their day with a sense of routine, exchange pleasantries as they pass each other on the windy dirt roads and share an alcoholic beverage at the dimly-lit local pub of an afternoon.

One matter has become the talk of the town.  Two lifelong friends, Colm (Gleeson) and Pádraic (Farrell), have had a bizarre, unexpected falling out.  Colm, the instigator of the separation, says it has nothing to do with anything Pádraic did or said.  It’s simply because “I just don’t like you no more” and he then asks a confused Colm never to speak with him ever again.

What follows is a riveting drama that asks us to look deeply at these characters and form an opinion about them and their actions.  Who’s in the right and who’s in the wrong?  Is it that clear cut?  Should Colm be allowed to sever the friendship without a more reasonable explanation?  Is Pádraic out of line for continuing to pester Colm and those around him in search of justification?  To what extent are we entitled to our own privacy as opposed to having to consider the feelings of caring friends around us?

The film also has something to say about the way small disagreements can, through events outside of our control, escalate into things much bigger than anyone anticipated… or wanted.  Townsfolk start gossiping about the pair and, just like a game of Chinese whispers, it reaches the point where innocuous speculation and rumours morph into “facts”.  This only adds to the division between Colm and Pádraic and it threatens to disrupt other relationships with the community.

Every actor in this ensemble is at the top of their game.  Colin Farrell and Brendan Gleeson are reunited for the first time since the terrific In Bruges (a must-see if you haven’t already) and, churning out the thickest Irish accents they can, play off each other like skilled musicians.  The conversations they share are both humorous and dramatic.  Kerry Condon (Better Call Saul) is sensational as Pádraic’s level-headed sister while Barry Keoghan (The Killing of a Sacred Deer) steals a bunch of scenes a dim-witted yet likeable young man. 

Going down unexpected paths and tapping into the spiritual, The Banshees of Inisherin is another winner from Martin McDonagh that will be a factor in the upcoming awards season.  One of the year’s best.

Directed by: James Cameron
Written by: James Cameron, Rick Jaffa, Amanda Silver, Josh Friedman, Shane Salerno
Starring: Sam Worthington, Zoe Saldaña, Sigourney Weaver, Stephen Lang, Kate Winslet, Cliff Curtis, Jack Champion
Released: December 15, 2022
Grade: B+

Avatar: The Way of Water

In terms of filmmaking, there is very little, if anything, that James Cameron has left to prove.  He will go down in history as one of the most successful directors of all time.  His early years featured classics such as Aliens, The Abyss, and the first two Terminator movies.  In 1997, Titanic won a record 11 Academy Awards (the record still stands) and became the highest grossing movie of all time in the United States.  That benchmark stood for 12 years until Cameron’s very next film, Avatar, bettered Titanic’s domestic gross in just 47 days and would go on to make a phenomenal $2.75 billion at the global box-office.

Having waited over a decade, Cameron finally takes audiences back to the world of Pandora for another adventure involving our beloved blue characters.  It’s epic in terms of cost ($350-$400 million), epic in terms of duration (193 minutes), and epic in terms of technological advancement.  The film has been shot to make the most of 3D cinema (which we haven’t seen much of in recent years) and certain action scenes utilise the smoother, but seldom used, 48 frames per second rate as opposed to the traditional 24.

Avatar: The Way of Water provides an incredible spectacle.  The visuals make you think that every other action flick of the past decade was made in the 1950s.  It’s head-scratching that Cameron can create such a stunningly beautiful world with bright, clear, easy-to-follow battles (the sound effects are great too) while all other directors keep churning out the same dark, grainy, repetitive-looking stuff.  Maybe it’s a budget thing?  Maybe Cameron is simply in a league of his own?

I’m not as enthusiastic when it comes to narrative.  I was never bored in Avatar: The Way of Water but the five-person writing team take few chances and go down a familiar, well-worth path.  I feel like I’ve seen this type of action story 10,000 times now – one where people make reckless decisions and put their lives in danger because nothing is more important than “family” and keeping them safe.  Given the 68-year-old Cameron has three more sequels planned, it could give The Fast and The Furious franchise a run for its money in who pushes the family theme hardest. 

To provide a quick synopsis, the Earth is still dying and a small group of well-armed human soldiers are hoping to “pacify” the Na’vi locals on Pandora and take over the planet as their own.  Their latest scheme is to adopt Na’vi avatars, sneak through local defences, and take down Jake Sully (Worthington), the heroic human-turned-Na’vi who has become a thorn in their side.  In addition to Jake, the “good guy” side includes his partner (Saldaña), their four kids, a new clan of people, a teenager named “Spider” (Champion), and a bunch of super-smart fish.  Some subplots are resolved whilst others will carry over into future movies.

Considering all other studios have run for the hills and are putting up nothing against it (last week’s box-office in the U.S. was the worst in 11 months), Avatar: The Way of Water will be one of this year’s biggest hits.  See it on the biggest screen you can find.  It’s review-proof.

Directed by: Will Speck, Josh Gordon
Written by: William Davies
Starring: Javier Bardem, Constance Wu, Winslow Fegley, Scott McNairy, Brett Geiman, Shawn Mendes
Released: December 26, 2022
Grade: B+

Lyle, Lyle, Crocodile

It’s not going to change the world but as a film trying to offer laughs, entertainment, and big-hearted messages for younger audiences, Lyle, Lyle, Crocodile fulfils its mission.  Adults won’t mind it either.  The source material is a 48-page children’s picture book authored by American Bernard Waber and first published in 1965.  I haven’t read it myself (must have missed it in kindergarten) but it’s easy to see the appeal given it’s centred on a cute crocodile who knows how to sing.

I’m reminded of an animated feature we saw earlier in the year, The Bad Guys, in that it reminds us not to “judge a book by its cover”.  The instinctive reaction is to run away from a crocodile (and several characters do that in this movie) but as we soon learn, Lyle is a shy, clumsy, sensitive creature who we shouldn’t fear.  The first member of the Primm family to realise this is Josh (Fegley), a young boy who discovers the crocodile hiding in the attic of a New York City townhouse recently rented by his two busy parents (Wu and McNairy).

The singing Lyle (voiced by Shawn Mendes) becomes the catalyst for good things.  The introverted Josh is struggling with a new school and a new city but, thanks to Lyle’s playful antics, he “comes out of his shell” and develops confidence and independence.  It’s not long before Josh’s parents learn about Lyle (it’s hard to hide a crocodile) and, somewhat unexpectedly, it brings the family closer together and more receptive to overdue changes (like the dinner menu).

Brought to the screen by the directing team of Will Speck and Josh Gordon (Blades of Glory, Office Christmas Party), Lyle, Lyle, Crocodile moves at a quick pace and doesn’t get bogged down with superfluous subplots.  A great example is Lyle’s backstory which features a fun supporting performance from Javier Bardem (No Country For Old Men) who first finds a baby Lyle in an exotic animals store. Covering these details in a speedy introduction frees up more time for us to get to the film’s heart – the bond between Lyle and Josh.

13-year-old Winslow Fegley, the younger brother of Oakes Fegley (Pete’s Dragon, The War With Grandpa), is very good in a role that many children will relate to.  It’s nice to see a story that depicts anxiety (showing kids it’s something a lot of people go through) while showing there are ways to open up and deal with it.  These real-life themes are nicely balanced against the humorous absurdity of a singing crocodile living in New York City.

Released on Boxing Day alongside the equally likeable Puss in Boots: The Last Wish here in Australia, there’s no shortage of quality family offerings this holiday season.

Directed by: Matthew Warchus
Written by: Dennis Kelly
Starring: Alisha Weir, Lashana Lynch, Stephen Graham, Andrea Riseborough, Emma Thompson, Sindhu Vee
Released: December 8, 2022
Grade: B+

Matilda the Musical

There is no doubt (warning: there may be doubt) that Matilda the Musical is one of the best stage shows of the 21st Century.  Roald Dahl’s 1988 novel was already terrific… but Dennis Kelly (book) and Tim Minchin (music and lyrics) transformed it into a musical which is just as memorable.  It’s humorous, it’s emotional, and it’s not afraid to get really dark (a rarity when it comes to family-oriented stuff).  It boasts a fantastic, well-crafted music score and, through performances across the world, has allowed a plethora of young actors to showcase their rising talents.

It was always a matter of when, not if, the show would be adapted for the big screen.  It has been spruiked since 2013 and after years of waiting, director Matthew Warchus (also responsible for the stage musical) has finally completed what fans have been waiting for.  It’s not a like-for-like adaptation however.  A few changes have been made to trim roughly 20 minutes and have it sneak in under the two hour mark (for the benefit of those with shorter attention spans).

If you’re new to the material, it’s the tale of super smart young girl named Matilda who is the product of two selfish, ignorant, rotten parents.  Unable to find proper adult guidance at home, two kind people fill the gap – a knowledgeable librarian who provides wonderful books to read, and a softly-spoken schoolteacher who can easily detect Matilda’s intelligence.  In addition to the parents, there’s one more villain threatening to upend Matilda’s life – the nasty, power-hungry school headmaster who thinks of children like scum.

I’m a fan of Matthew Warchus (Pride) but the direction here is a little scrappy and haphazard.  When compared to some of the great modern day movie musicals (e.g. Moulin Rouge, Chicago, La La Land) you’ll realise the elaborate musical numbers don’t flow smoothly.  A little magic has been lost in the editing room with the uneven mix of close-ups and long shots.  One exception is the “School Song” which comes across very well.

Despite those qualms, it’s hard not to be won over by this movie given the strength of the source material.  The songs are so damn good!  Warchus has also struck gold in finding 13-year-old star Alisha Weir who has a fantastic voice and the perfect look for the title role.  She beat out thousands of others as part of a lengthy audition process.  Emma Thompson continues her sensational year (hot on the heels of Good Luck to You, Leo Grande) and creates an ideal can’t-wait-till-she-gets-what-she-deserves villain in headmaster Miss Trunchbull.

It’s hard to match the joy and energy that comes from a live performance and while this adaption falls a touch short, it’s still heaps of fun.

Directed by: Ruben Östlund
Written by: Ruben Östlund
Starring: Harris Dickinson, Charlbi Dean, Dolly de Leon, Zlatko Burić, Iris Berben, Woody Harrelson
Released: December 26, 2022
Grade: A-

Triangle of Sadness

Winning one Palme d’or (the top prize at the Cannes Film Festival) is a career-defining achievement but to win two is something special.  It’s a position that 48-year-old Swedish filmmaker Ruben Östlund (Force Majeure) now finds himself in.  He won the award in 2017 for his offbeat dark comedy The Square and he’s followed it up five years later with his next film, Triangle of Sadness.  It’s worth noting that, coincidence or not, both titles contain the name of a shape.

This latest effort is split into three chapters which have overlapping characters but different settings.  It opens by introducing us to two young, good-looking models (Dickinson and Dean) who argue about etiquette when paying the bill at a restaurant.  The middle act takes place on a $250 million luxury yacht where the hard-working staff and alcoholic captain (Harrelson) tend to the needs of the uber-wealthy guests.  The climax is reminiscent of William Golding’s Lord of the Flies and sees a group of people fending for surviving after becoming stuck on a deserted island.

It’s heavy handed in places but Triangle of Sadness can be admired for many reasons.  It’s a great film to discuss with friends as you dissect the themes being explored in relation to class structures within society.  As articulated by Östlund in interviews, it also has something to say about “good looks” being used as currency.  Whether we like it or not, we live in a world where beauty can be just as important, if not more so, than brains as people climb corporate and social ladders.

For those who don’t want to delve deeply into messages, Triangle of Sadness can still be enjoyed as an outlandish spectacle.  The lengthy scene where the two models disagree about who should pay for dinner is reminiscent of a Curb Your Enthusiasm skit.  A sequence where cruise ship guests become violently ill after eating a lavish dinner in the middle of a storm could be borrowed from low-brow comedy given the abundance of shit and vomit.  The open-endedness to several subplots in the film’s finale taps into a director’s fun in teasing audiences (such as Christopher Nolan in Inception).

Of the cast, Philippines-born Dolly de Leon is getting the most awards season attention thus far for her hilarious performance as a cleaning lady who comes to prominence in the final act.  She’s terrific but so too is the broader ensemble.  Some actors only appear in a handful of scenes by they leave an impression – a great example being Swedish actress Mia Benson as a deluded guest who demands the yacht’s non-existent sails be cleaned.  There’s a tinge of sadness to the film’s release however given the unexpected death of 32-year-old star Charlbi Dean (who plays Yaya) in August.

Ruben Östlund could never be accused of creating dull movies and if looking for something wild and eyebrow-raising, Triangle of Sadness fits the bill.